Women's Softball
Messiah University
NCAA D3 · MAC Commonwealth · Mechanicsburg, PA
29-17
2026 record
67%
Win rate, 3yr
$23.2k
Avg net price
75%
Grad rate
The program
Under Amy Weaver: 416-189 since 1997
Amy Weaver, Head coach · 29 seasons · aweaver@messiah.edu
Assistants: Alex Quigley · Brad Brubaker (Assistant Coach) · Erin Darhower (P/T Assistant Coach) · Michaela Cotton (P/T Assistant Coach) · Taylor Dorman (P/T Assistant Coach)
The roster · 2025
Haylie Fenstermaker
Fr. · Outfield
Slatington, Pa.
Hannah Dyer
Sr. · Infield
Millersburg, Pa.
Shaylee Greenland
Fr. · Pitcher
Towanda, Pa.
Allie Book
Jr. · Infield/Outfield
Fallston, Md.
Lucy Murphy
Fr. · Infield/Outfield
Rochester, N.Y.
Kandice Schlabach
Sr. · Outfield
Greenwood, Del.
Elizabeth Donofry
So. · Outfield/Utility
Alpha, N.J.
Sierra Emery
Sr. · Outfield
Bernardsville, N.J.
Ali Wagner
Sr. · Outfield
Camp Hill, Pa.
Kylie Thompson
Fr. · Outfield
Frederick, Md.
Maeve Hurley
Fr. · Pitcher
Newville, Pa.
Rebekah Wiley
Jr. · Catcher/Infield
Dillsburg, Pa.
Asia Harding
Fr. · Outfield
New Castle, Del.
Alexis Barker
Fr. · Infield
New Cumberland, Pa.
Fallon Feaser
So. · Pitcher / Utility
Newville, Pa.
Maggie Chinnadurai
Sr. · Pitcher
Denville, N.J.
Kelli Durbin
Jr. · Pitcher
Mount Airy, Md.
Katie Alexander
Fr. · Infield
Damascus, Md.
A sample of the roster.
Roster turnover
Players graduating after the 2025 season, by position.
Where they're from
Cost & academics
Net cost after aid, by family income
SAT 25-75%
1110-1350
Grad rate
75%
Admit rate
79%
Enrollment
2k
Also in the MAC Commonwealth
Can you play here?
Build your Target Map to see where this program fits your numbers, your real cost, and your path to the field.
Build your Target Map