Women's Softball
John Carroll University
NCAA D3 · North Coast Athletic Conference · University Heights, OH
14-19
2026 record
33%
Win rate, 3yr
$25.6k
Avg net price
79%
Grad rate
The program
Under Tony Scibelli: 26-37 since 2025
Tony Scibelli, Head coach · 1 season · ascibelli@jcu.edu
Assistants: Kelsey Bernhard · Libby Fickel · Matt McPeek · Reese Politowski (Student Manager) · Sophia Crespo (Student Manager)
The roster · 2026
Paige Riney
So. · Utility
Perrysburg, OH
Alyssa McPeek
So. · Catcher/Infielder
Willoughby, OH
Lydia Pratt
So. · Infielder
Columbus, OH
Izzy White
Fy. · Infielder
New Albany, OH
Elizabeth Hohlefelder
So. · Infielder
Dublin, OH
Cam Chimera
So. · Utility
Erie, PA
Norah Bradley
So. · Pitcher/Infielder
Davison, MI
Katherine Nativio
So. · Outfielder
New Castle, PA
Elaina Rodriguez
Sr. · Utility
Avon, OH
Gianna DiFranco
So. · Infielder
Kirtland, OH
Casey Cash
Sr. · Pitcher
Valley City, OH
Kaylinn Samuelraj
So. · Pitcher/Infielder
Solon, OH
Jordan Anderson
Gr. · Pitcher/Infield
Alliance, OH
Jordan Bradford
So. · Pitcher/Infield
Wellington, OH
Alicia Varacky
So. · Infielder
Canal Fulton, OH
Gayle Mishic
Fy. · Catcher/Utility
Richfield, OH
Bella Carcioppolo
Sr. · Utility
Mentor, OH
Kristin Dems
Jr. · Pitcher
Mentor, OH
A sample of the roster.
Roster turnover
Players graduating after the 2026 season, by position.
Where they're from
Cost & academics
Net cost after aid, by family income
SAT 25-75%
1180-1330
Grad rate
79%
Admit rate
81%
Enrollment
2k
Also in the North Coast Athletic Conference
Can you play here?
Build your Target Map to see where this program fits your numbers, your real cost, and your path to the field.
Build your Target Map