Women's Softball
Butler University
NCAA D1 · Big East Conference · Indianapolis, IN
25-21
2026 record
51%
Win rate, 3yr
$32.3k
Avg net price
80%
Grad rate
The program
Scott Hall, Head coach · sahall@butler.edu
Assistants: Bryce Small · Cory Rywalt · Mallory Winters '12 · Morgan Robertson (Student Assistant) · Renee Milos, ATC · Sean O'Brien
The roster · 2026
Emily Todor
Sr. · OF
Trafalgar, Ind.
Hailey Conger
Sr. · OF
Gurnee, Ill.
Rachel Hunt
Fr. · IF
South Bend, Ind.
Olivia Roberts
Jr. · IF
Greenfield, Ind.
Olivia Robards
Sr. · IF
Evansville, Ind.
Paxton Law
So. · U
Carmel, Ind.
Alona Boydston
So. · C
Kenosha, Wis.
Makena Alexander
Jr. · IF
Frankton, Ind.,
Maren Berger
R-So. · P
Snowflake, Ariz.
Kieli Ryan
Sr. · C
Ingals, Ind.
Cate Lehner
Sr. · OF
Indianapolis, Ind.
Alyx Johnson
Fr. · P/IF
Watertown, Wis.
Paige Lillie
So. · P/IF
Appleton, Wis.
Katie Petran
Jr. · P
Chillicothe, Ill.,
Erin Clark
Jr. · OF
Noblesville, Ind.
Kendall Graves
Fr. · IF
Bedford, Ind.
Kate Murray
Fr. · P
Fishers, Ind.
Rylyn Dyer
Sr. · P
Hamersville, Ohio
A sample of the roster.
Roster turnover
Players graduating after the 2026 season, by position.
Where they're from
Cost & academics
Net cost after aid, by family income
SAT 25-75%
1160-1350
Grad rate
80%
Admit rate
85%
Enrollment
4k
Also in the Big East Conference
Can you play here?
Build your Target Map to see where this program fits your numbers, your real cost, and your path to the field.
Build your Target Map